Worldwide scandal in the Catholic Church

Revised from the BBC report:
“Catholic Church sex abuse scandals around the world”

The Catholic Church has faced a raft of allegations of child sex abuse by priests and an inadequate response by bishops. To date, allegations are abundant.

  1. In Belgium: The bishop of Bruges, Roger Vangheluwe, resigned in April 2010 after admitting that he had sexually abused a boy for years when he was a priest and after being made a bishop. After the Vangheluwe case came to light, a commission was set up to investigate the extent of abuse and released harrowing details of some 300 cases of alleged sexual abuse by Belgian clergy. Of these thirteen alleged victims had committed suicide. No evidence indicated that the Church sought to cover up the abuse.
  2. In Ireland: Two major reports into allegations of paedophilia among Irish clergy last year revealed the shocking extent of abuse, cover-ups and hierarchical failings involving thousands of victims, and stretching back decades. The Dublin archdiocese, it said, operated in a culture of concealment, placing the integrity of its institutions above the welfare of the children in its care. Four Dublin archbishops were found to have effectively turned a blind eye to cases of abuse from 1975 to 2004, Additionally, some six decades of physical, sexual and emotional abuse were uncovered at residential institutions run by 18 religious orders. Furthermore, in March 2010, the commission discovered that the head of the Irish Catholic Church, Cardinal Sean Brady, was present when the abused children signed vows of silence thereby protecting a paedophile priest
  3. In the United States: A report commissioned by the Church found more than 4,000 US Roman Catholic priests had faced sexual abuse allegations in the last 50 years, in cases involving more than 10,000 children - mostly boys. A series of huge payouts has been made by US diocese to alleged victims of abuse - the largest being some $660m in 2007 from the Los Angeles Archdiocese. During a tour of the US in 2008, the Pope met privately with victims of abuse by priests and spoke of "the pain and the harm inflicted by the sexual abuse of minors". In March 2010 documents emerged suggesting that Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, before he became Pope, failed to respond to letters from US clergy about cases of alleged child sex abuse by a priest in Wisconsin. Archbishops had complained about Fr Lawrence Murphy in 1996 to a Vatican office led by the future Pope, but apparently received no response.
  4. Germany: Since the start of 2010, at least 300 people have made allegations of sexual or physical abuse by priests. Claims are being investigated in 18 of Germany's 27 Roman Catholic dioceses. Accusations include the abuse of more than 170 children by priests at Jesuit schools, three Catholic schools in Bavaria, and within the Regensburg Domspatzen school boys' choir that was directed for 30 years by Monsignor Georg Ratzinger, the Pope's brother.
    And, Father Peter Hullermann, who was convicted of molesting boys during his time in the archdiocese of Munich and Freising, was suspended from his duties after breaching a ban on working with children.
  5. In Italy: In June 2010 a high-profile former priest was charged with sexual abuse of 12 young people at a drug rehabilitation centre he founded. Later last year the Associated Press news agency obtained a written statement from 67 of the school's former pupils naming 24 priests, brothers and lay religious men who they accused of sexual abuse, paedophilia and corporal punishment.
  6. In Netherlands: In March 2010, Dutch bishops ordered an independent inquiry into more than 200 allegations of sexual abuse of children by priests. Allegations first centred on Don Rua monastery school in the eastern Netherlands, with people saying they were abused by Catholic priests in the 1960s and 70s. This prompted dozens more alleged victims from other institutions to come forward.
  7. In Austria: A series of claims of sexual abuse by priests has emerged in the Vorarlberg region. Some 16 people have reported 27 alleged incidents there, spanning half a century. Ten children are alleged to have been abused at a monastery in Mehrerau in the 1970s and early 80s. Five priests at a monastery in Kremsmuenster in Upper Austria have been suspended after complaints of sexual and physical abuse of boys there. Separately, the head of a Salzburg monastery, Bruno Becker, resigned after confessing to having abused a boy 40 years ago, when he was a monk.
  8. In Switzerland: A commission set up by the Swiss Bishops Conference reported that 60 people have said they were abused by Catholic priests. The alleged incidents are reported to have occurred over the past 15 years. 1

[Editor's Commentary] These acts and allegations reveal an appalling behavior by both priests and bishops. However, it shouldn't come as a complete surprise that priest are capable of grave sins. We do not know the specific causes of the fall of these priests anymore than we can defintively state the causes of pedophilia, even though there is a strong correlation that pedophiles were abused as children. But certainly, we should take into account the intent of these abuses. It is known, by a great deal of research, that pedophilia activities are extensively planned. Pedophiles seek positions of respect and authority to hide their intent, are very clever and adept in grooming their targets, and are skilled in presenting themselves as very reputable individuals. Hence, seeking respectable positions as clergy, teachers, and coaches, where they are around children, are very attractive

It should also be noted that the great majority of these allegations reference crimes more than 10 years old, and that the Church has been frank and straight forward in cooperating with civil authorities. Over this time the investigation and selection of clerics has undergone extensive re-evaluation. Obviously, these precedures weren't as strict and through in the past as they are today, and it is a credit to the Church that it has accepted full responsibility, made restitution, and has taken strong measures to protect its parishioners, particularly innocent children.

It, also, should not be surprisinmg that bishops would seek to protect priests and the Church. Protecting the reputation of Church is somewhat ingrained, almost as ingrained as protecting the reputation of sinners under the seal of confession. Even with that in mind, there were means available to protect the innocent by counselling, removing faculties, or by laicizing offending priests. That the bishops chose not to do so is certainly a derilection of duty. However, the Church, in response to these scandals, has taken extensive and effective steps to guard against future abuses. This is highly laudable - much more so than that of the American Congress that has a slush fund to cover such allegations and crimes. Thus, society needs to be as forthright, using the experience of the Church as a model. Those, who are critical of the Church, may need to clean their own houses as well.

However, even given the strong steps the Church has taken, it rocks our faith that such a thing can happen by those who are called to be examples of holiness. For the faithful, its important to differentiate the sins of individuals, and the mismanagement of priests, from the fundamental doctrine that was give to the Church by Christ himself. Though believers, even priests, may stumble and fall, the teaching and holiness of the Church will prevail because it is the Body of Christ and is protected by the Holy Spirit. With a responsiveness to these issues, and an acceptance of guilt and responsibility, the remant of Catholic Church will emerge stronger and more faithful, though many will be lost because of the scandal.

Good Fences Make Good Neighbors

Saint Thomas Aquinas once said “Quarrels arise more frequently when there is no division of the things possessed." However, it would be erroneous to interpret these words as relating only to physical boundaries or personal property. More importantly, they refer to personal, psychological, and spiritual boundaries. Walls exist because sin and disorder exists. Scandals arise, and evil flourishes, where God given rights and societal norms are violated; where the attraction for our passions overrides the respect and love our neighbor is due. As the conservative social historian, Russel Kirk, once said, "Order is the first need of the soul." In the beginning, prior to all creation, God brought order out of chaos. Where there are no boundaries, where rights are violated, where laws are trampled, freedom is destroyed and chaos and evil reigns. And where walls are damaged, and in need of repair, neighbors need to work together to mend those fences and restore proper respect and boundaries.

Recent Additions

Pope Francis Institutes New
Celebration of Mary

Virgin Mary

Virgin Mary by Michaelangelo Buonaroti 1

“Mother of the Church”

Pope Francis has decreed that the ancient devotion to the Blessed Virgin Mary, under the title of Mother of the Church, be inserted into the Roman Calendar.

Baruch Hashem!

Hebrew: "Blessed be the Name of the Lord."

Art Links

Building Community

Quick Links

Cartoon: golf ball driving a golf cart

Vision Amid Scandal

Revised from an article by
Dan Burke of the Avila Foundation

As I reflect on the challenges in the Church this past year, it easily draws me to sorrow. Even so, I see a powerful light piercing through the dark clouds onto the valley floor. This light is the light of Christ that no cloud of corruption can permanently obscure. This is a light that never ceases to pierce and dispel the darkness. This is a light that has a name, His name is Jesus. His name and His Church are the reason I exist. He is my purpose, our purpose, our salvation.

As we enter into Advent, the dawn of our salvation, we are reminded of the Light that once came and comes again at every Mass. This Light shined in the darkness then, and it does so now. It breaks the darkness of broken hearts and minds ... It ignites the minds of future priests. It is the light that beckons the hearts of all Christians to noble and holy vocations. These are the lights of God that He has given us to give to the world. 2

See something different

From an Ordination Homily by
Archbishop of Atlanta, John Donohue

In a time when the Church is plagued by scandal and attacked from all sides, it is clear that these men see something different, something noble, something worthy of their lives. 3

'I am wounded by love'

What, I ask, is more wonderful than the beauty of God? What thought is more pleasing and wonderful than God’s majesty? What desire is as urgent and overpowering as the desire implanted by God in a soul that is completely purified of sin and cries out in its love: I am wounded by love? The radiance of divine beauty is altogether beyond the power of words to describe.

- Saint Basil the Great